1. 首页
  2. 法律委托案例
  3. 陈勇与上海禹凌船务有限公司等船舶经营管理合同纠纷上诉案((2012)沪高民四(海)终字第11号)

陈勇与上海禹凌船务有限公司等船舶经营管理合同纠纷上诉案((2012)沪高民四(海)终字第11号)

陈勇与上海禹凌船务有限公司等船舶经营管理合同纠纷上诉案上海市高级人民法院民事判决书(2012)沪高民四(海)终字第11号上诉人(原审被告)陈勇。被上诉人(原审原告)上海禹凌船务有限公司。法定代表人陈彬,该公司董事长。委托代理人郑曦,福建大佳律师事务所律师。被上诉人(原审被告)刘宁。上诉人陈勇因船舶经营管理合同纠纷一案,不服上海海事法院(2011)沪海法商初字第184号民事判决,向本院提起上诉。本院于2011年12月30日立案受理后,依法组成合议庭,并于2012年6月4日公开开...

陈勇与上海禹凌船务有限公司等船舶经营管理合同纠纷上诉案

上海市高级人民法院

民事判决书

(2012)沪高民四(海)终字第11号

上诉人(原审被告)陈勇。

被上诉人(原审原告)上海禹凌船务有限公司。

法定代表人陈彬,该公司董事长。

委托代理人郑曦,福建大佳律师事务所律师。

被上诉人(原审被告)刘宁。

上诉人陈勇因船舶经营管理合同纠纷一案,不服上海海事法院(2011)沪海法商初字第184号民事判决,向本院提起上诉。本院于2011年12月30日立案受理后,依法组成合议庭,并于2012年6月4日公开开庭进行了审理。陈勇及被上诉人上海禹凌船务有限公司(以下简称禹凌公司)的委托代理人郑曦到庭参加了诉讼。被上诉人刘宁经本院依法传唤,无正当理由未到庭参加诉讼。本案现已审理终结。

原审法院经审理查明:2007年12月3日,禹凌公司与刘宁、陈勇签订合作协议,约定共同光租经营新捷达轮,投资比例为刘宁40%、陈勇55%、陈彬5%,由刘宁全权负责船舶营运,以禹凌公司名义对外订立货运合同,船舶的正常营运操作支出由刘宁决定支付,超过人民币10万元(以下币种均为人民币)的支出必须通知其他二方。2008年11月28日,禹凌公司与刘宁、陈勇签订股东决议,约定在三方共同租船经营期间,由新捷达轮所产生的债权债务而引起的相关法律费用和债务、修理费由三方按合作协议中的投资比例承担。

2008年8月22日至2009年1月15日,船员蔡纪屈在新捷达轮工作,担任轮机长一职,约定工资为21,000元/月,后经协商调整为16,000元/月。2009年1月8日,禹凌公司支付给蔡纪屈伙食费2,000元,2009年8月3日,禹凌公司支付给蔡纪屈工资76,266元。

2009年1月14日至2009年11月27日,船员陈国锋在新捷达轮工作,担任水手长一职,约定工资为4,000元/月,约定伙食费标准为17元/天,禹凌公司共支付给陈国锋工资41,791元,伙食费5,389元。2009年1月14日至2009年8月21日,船员邢新辉在新捷达轮工作,担任机工一职,约定工资为2,300元/月,约定伙食费标准为17元/天,禹凌公司共支付给邢新辉工资16,619元,伙食费3,740元。此外,在陈国锋和邢新辉上船工作期间,禹凌公司共支付了车费、补贴、购买日用品等费用共计9,136.50元。

2009年2月17日,原审法院作出(2008)沪海法商初字第948号民事判决。秦皇岛新远船舶机械设备有限公司不服该判决向上海市高级人民法院提出上诉。2009年6月26日,上海市高级人民法院作出(2009)沪高民四(海)终字第68号民事判决,判令本案禹凌公司向秦皇岛新远船舶机械设备有限公司支付货款73,410元及利息并承担该案一、二审的案件受理费2,227.85元。2009年7月31日,原审法院发出执行通知书,责令本案禹凌公司在2009年8月4日前履行上述民事判决的内容,并承担申请执行费1,036.55元。2009年8月3日,本案禹凌公司向原审法院支付了76,674.40元。

2007年12月27日,禹凌公司与福州海凌船务有限公司签订了《船舶安全和防污染委托管理合同》及《新捷达轮安全管理合同补充协议(一)》,约定由福州海凌船务有限公司接受禹凌公司委托对新捷达轮实施安全和防污染管理,为禹凌公司配备合格船员,负责船舶的保养及管理等工作,并约定委托管理费为90,000元/年,其中45,000元在协议签订后三个银行工作日内支付,余款45,000元在以签订日为准满半年后一次性支付。2009年6月29日,福州海凌船务有限公司向禹凌公司发出催款通知书,要求禹凌公司尽快支付尚欠的管理费45,000元。2009年8月3日,禹凌公司向福州海凌船务有限公司支付了船舶管理费45,000元。

2010年6月7日,原审法院作出(2010)沪海法商初字第325号民事判决,判令本案禹凌公司向上海深水港船务有限公司支付救助费60,000元并承担案件受理费650元,该判决已生效,但禹凌公司至今尚未履行生效判决的内容。

2009年6月17日,原审法院作出(2009)沪海法商初字第337号民事判决,判令本案禹凌公司向薛友昌支付工资及履约金49,477.70元并承担案件受理费645.95元。2009年11月30日,原审法院发出(2009)沪海法执字第363号执行通知书,责令本案禹凌公司履行上述民事判决的内容,并承担申请执行费。2009年12月18日,原审法院发出(2009)沪海法商初字第1090、1091、1092、1155号民事调解书,确认本案禹凌公司应分别向杨胜兵、刘美铵、王建国、王家宝支付80,000元、14,700元、64,482元、44,163.70元,并承担案件受理费。2010年2月4日,原审法院发出(2010)沪海法执字第40-43号执行通知书,责令本案禹凌公司履行上述民事调解书的内容,并承担申请执行费。2011年4月6日,本案禹凌公司向原审法院支付了259,120.56元。

2009年8月12日,原审法院作出(2009)沪海法商初字第450号民事判决,判令本案禹凌公司向上海博丰石油化工有限公司支付燃油款870,363.43元及利息,并承担案件受理费12,314.28元,该判决已生效。2009年9月21日,原审法院发出执行通知,责令本案禹凌公司于2009年9月24日前履行上述民事判决的内容,并承担申请执行费11,244.72元。但禹凌公司至今尚未履行。

2009年6月11日,原审法院审理了本案禹凌公司与本案刘宁、陈勇船舶经营管理合同纠纷一案,并作出(2009)沪海法商初字第231号民事判决,对于本案禹凌公司在新捷达轮经营期间垫付的修理费、燃油款、船员工资等费用,本案刘宁、陈勇应当按照合作协议及股东决议的约定,分别按照投资比例承担各自的债务。陈勇不服提出上诉。2010年2月5日,上海市高级人民法院作出(2009)沪高民四(海)终字第243号民事判决书维持原判。

2010年10月27日,中国海事仲裁委员会上海分会作出(2010)海仲沪裁字第033号仲裁裁决,裁定本案禹凌公司应向上海大通船务工程有限公司支付船舶配件费及律师费、仲裁费共计37,303.47元。上海大通船务工程有限公司不服,向原审法院申请撤销该仲裁裁决。原审法院于2011年3月14日作出(2010)沪海法特字第12号民事裁定,驳回上海大通船务工程有限公司的申请。2011年5月24日,本案禹凌公司向上海大通船务工程有限公司支付了上述费用及申请执行费共计37,763.47元。2011年6月17日,本案禹凌公司与上海大通船务工程有限公司达成和解协议,约定由本案禹凌公司向上海大通船务工程有限公司支付新捷达轮的修理费43,000元,上海大通船务工程有限公司收到该笔费用后即向原审法院申请撤诉。同日,原审法院作出(2011)沪海法商初字第485号民事裁定,准许上海大通船务工程有限公司撤回对本案禹凌公司的起诉。

Chen Yong and Wu of boat of approach of Shanghai the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty the record of appeal of dispute of shipping management contract such as limited company

Shanghai is advanced people court

Civil judgment

(2012) Shanghai Gao Min 4 (the sea) eventually word the 11st

Appellant (first trial the accused) Chen Yong.

Appellee (first trial accuser) Wu of boat of approach of Shanghai the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty limited company.

Legal representative Chen Bin, this company president.

Attorney Zheng sunlights, solicitor of office of attorney of Fujian large fine.

Appellee (first trial the accused) Liu Ning.

Appellant Chen Yong because dispute of shipping management contract one case, refuse to obey Shanghai admiralty courtyard (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2011) Shanghai sea the 184th civil judgment, mention to this academy appeal. This academy after put on record was accepted on December 30, 2011, comprise collegiate bench lawfully, undertook cognizance at making public open a court session on June 4, 2012. Chen Yong and Wu of boat of approach of appellee Shanghai the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty limited company (company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty of the following abbreviation) attorney Zheng Xi joined suit to front courtyard. This academy of appellee Liu peaceful classics lawfully subpoena, did not join suit to front courtyard without warrant. This case already was tried now terminative.

First trial court finds out via cognizance: On December 3, 2007, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty and Liu Ning, Chen Yong signs cooperative agreement, the agreement hires management Xin Jie to amount to solely jointly annulus, investment scale coulds there be for Liu 40% , Chen Yong 55% , Chen Bin 5% , by Liu Ning full-fledged member is in charge of shipping battalion carrying, with Yu Ling company name concludes external freight contract, normal battalion carry operates marine defray is decided to pay by Liu Ning, exceed a RMB 100 thousand yuan (the following money is planted all be a RMB) defray must inform other 2. On November 28, 2008, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty and Liu Ning, Chen Yong signs shareholder resolution, during agreeing in tripartite collective chartering is managed, the creditor's rights debt that amounts to round of place to arise by Xin Jie and the relevant law cost that cause and debt, investment scale in repairing cost to press cooperative agreement by tripartite is assumed.

Came on August 22, 2008 on January 15, 2009, cai Ji bends the sailor to amount to round of job in Xin Jie, hold the position of a chief engineer one duty, conventional salary is 21, 000 yuan / month, adjust via talking things over after for 16, 000 yuan / month. On January 8, 2009, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty pays Cai Ji to bend board expense 2, 000 yuan, on August 3, 2009, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty pays Cai Ji Qu Gong endowment 76, 266 yuan.

Came on January 14, 2009 on November 27, 2009, sailor Chen Guofeng amounts to round of job in Xin Jie, hold the position of boatswain one duty, conventional salary is 4, 000 yuan / month, standard of conventional board expense is 17 yuan / day, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty pays Chen Guofeng salary in all 41, 791 yuan, board expense 5, 389 yuan. Came on January 14, 2009 on August 21, 2009, sailor Xing Xin Hui amounts to round of job in Xin Jie, hold the position of mechanic one duty, conventional salary is 2, 300 yuan / month, standard of conventional board expense is 17 yuan / day, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty pays Xing Xinhui salary in all 16, 619 yuan, board expense 3, 740 yuan. In addition, during Chen Guofeng and Xing Xinhui work aboard, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty paid fare, subsidy in all, buy the charge such as commodity to add up to 9, 136.5 yuan.

On Feburary 17, 2009, first trial court is made (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2008) Shanghai sea the 948th civil judgment. Machinery of new far boats and ships sets island of emperor of the Qin Dynasty have limited company refuses to obey should adjudicate to Shanghai senior people court puts forward to appeal. On June 26, 2009, senior people court makes Shanghai (2009) Shanghai Gao Min 4 (the sea) eventually word the 68th civil judgment, sentence make approach of this case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty general limited company of equipment of machinery of new far boats and ships pays island of Si Xiangqin emperor payment for goods 73, 410 yuan reach accrual and bear this record one, the case of 2 careful accepts fee 2, 227.85 yuan. On July 31, 2009, first trial court issues executive advice note, instruct company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty to fulfill the content of afore-mentioned civil judgments before August 4, 2009, assume application to implement fee 1, 36.55 yuan. On August 3, 2009, company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty paid to first trial court 76, 674.4 yuan.

On December 27, 2007, limited company signed company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty and Wu of boat of Fuzhou Hai Ling " shipping safety and prevent pollution to entrust administrative contract " reach " Xin Jie amounts to round of safety to run contract complement agreement (one) " , agree by Wu of boat of Fuzhou sea approach limited company accepts company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty to entrust pair of Xin Jie to amount to round of executive safety and defend contaminative management, for Yu Ling the company provides eligible crew, responsible marine maintains reach the job such as management, agree entrust administration fee for 90, 000 yuan / year, among them 45, 000 yuan pay inside weekday of 3 banks after the agreement is signed, more than 45, 000 yuan one-time after be accurate full half an year in order to sign day pay. On June 29, 2009, wu of boat of Fuzhou sea approach limited company issues the advice note that urge a fund to company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty, the administration fee that company of approach of requirement the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty pays Shang Qian as soon as possible 45, 000 yuan. On August 3, 2009, company of approach of the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty to Wu of boat of Fuzhou sea approach limited company paid shipping administration fee 45, 000 yuan.

On June 7, 2010, first trial court is made (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2010) Shanghai sea the 325th civil judgment, sentence make approach of this case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty general manage to Wu of boat of harbor of Shanghai deep water limited company pays deliverance fee 60, 000 yuan assume a case to accept fee 650 yuan, this court decision already become effective, dan Yuling company has not fulfill the content that become effective adjudicates up to now.

On June 17, 2009, first trial court is made (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2009) Shanghai sea the 337th civil judgment, sentence make a Xiangxue of company of approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty friendly prosperous pays salary to reach honor the agreement gold 49, 477.7 yuan assume a case to accept fee 645.95 yuan. On November 30, 2009, first trial court is given out (law of 2009) Shanghai sea hold the word carries out advice note the 363rd number, instruct company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty to fulfill the content of afore-mentioned civil judgments, assume application to implement fee. On December 18, 2009, first trial court is given out (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2009) Shanghai sea the 1090th, 1091, 1092, book of 1155 civil mediation, affirm company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty should part ammonium of Xiang Yangsheng arms, Liu Mei, Wang Jianguo, Wang Jiabao pays 80, 000 yuan, 14, 700 yuan, 64, 482 yuan, 44, 163.7 yuan, assume a case to accept fee. On Feburary 4, 2010, first trial court is given out (law of 2010) Shanghai sea hold 40-43 date carries out the word advice note, instruct company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty to fulfill the content of afore-mentioned civil mediation books, assume application to implement fee. On April 6, 2011, company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty paid to first trial court 259, 120.56 yuan.

On August 12, 2009, first trial court is made (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2009) Shanghai sea the 450th civil judgment, sentence make approach of this case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty general manage to Shanghai limited company of oily chemical industry pays Bo Fengshi fuel money 870, 363.43 yuan reach accrual, assume a case to accept fee 12, 314.28 yuan, this court decision already become effective. On September 21, 2009, first trial court issues executive announcement, order company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty at the content of afore-mentioned civil judgments is being fulfilled before September 24, 2009, assume application to implement fee 11, 244.72 yuan. Dan Yuling company had be notted fulfill up to now.

On June 11, 2009, first trial court heard dispute of company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty and contract of management of shipping of this case Liu peace, old brave one case, make (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2009) Shanghai sea the 231st civil judgment, amount to in Xin Jie to company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty annulus during managing of pay for sb and expect to be repaid later repair pay of money of cost, fuel, crew to wait for charge, this case Liu peace, Chen Yong ought to reach the agreement of shareholder resolution according to cooperative agreement, assume respective liability according to investment scale respectively. Chen Yong refuses to obey put forward to appeal. On Feburary 5, 2010, senior people court makes Shanghai (2009) Shanghai Gao Min 4 (the sea) eventually the 243rd civil judgment keeps the word original judgement.

On October 27, 2010, branch of Shanghai of maritime and arbitral committee makes China (2010) Hai Zhonghu dismisses a word the 033rd arbitral adjudication, rule company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty should connect limited company of boat Wu engineering to pay shipping fittings cost and retaining fee, arbitral cost to add up to greatly to Shanghai 37, 303.47 yuan. Limited company of engineering of Wu of Shanghai is big boat refuses to obey, to cancel of application of first trial court this arbitration adjudicates on. First trial court was made on March 14, 2011 (law of 2010) Shanghai sea is special word the 12nd civil ruling, reject Shanghai to open the application of limited company of boat Wu engineering greatly. On May 24, 2011, company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty paid afore-mentioned charge and application to carry out cost to add up to to limited company of engineering of Wu of Shanghai is big boat 37, 763.47 yuan. On June 17, 2011, limited company of engineering of Wu of company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty and Shanghai are big boat is reached reconcile agreement, the agreement connects limited company of boat Wu engineering to pay Xin Jie to amount to greatly to Shanghai by company of this approach of case the reputed founder of the Ix Dynasty annulus repair cost 43, 000 yuan, after limited company of engineering of Wu of Shanghai is big boat receives this fee, apply for to nolle prosequi to first trial court namely. With day, first trial court is made (the word at the beginning of business of law of 2011) Shanghai sea the 485th civil ruling, allow limited company of engineering of Wu of Shanghai is big boat recalls to this case of Yu Ling company sue.

本文来自投稿,不代表君士君法律咨询网立场,如若转载,请注明出处:http://www.junshijun.com/wts/26611.html